Troubling Rates of Local Homicide for Black Males

Our Staff


Troubling Rates of Local Homicide for Black Males

Antoinette Davis, Senior Program Specialist, NCCD

I met a young man on my commute home this week. While standing in line to board a bus, he started a conversation. As this sort of spontaneous exchange happens often with me, this experience will not surprise those who know me well. I like to attribute the phenomenon to my skills as a researcher or a genetic trait gifted by my gregarious mother. But the fact is this: I will talk to practically anyone. I welcome dialogue, which is evidenced by the varied and sometimes animated conversations I have during my daily Bay Area commute. However, this day was different. I was recovering from a cold brought home by my second grader, and I did not feel like talking. As a result, when I caught sight of a young man, clearly half my age, trying to make eye contact, I did my best to avoid his gaze and any form of conversation.  

I am pleased to report that I failed at this undertaking and ultimately engaged in a 30-minute conversation that began with a tap to my shoulder and the statement that he liked my hair. The young man then announced that his hair used to be like mine, but he cut it in order to get a job and thwart harassment from the police. He asked if I had those kinds of problems because of my hair. I answered honestly with a no and the acknowledgment that because I am a lot older and a woman, things are different for me. When he asked if I thought he was wrong for cutting his hair, I again answered no and said he was justified in doing whatever helped him to feel safe and to succeed legally in the workforce; he could always grow his hair out later in life. This felt like the “mom” answer; in fact, it is the type of statement I would make to my own son.

So we boarded the bus and talked. Actually, he talked. I listened, asked sporadic questions, and gave bits and pieces of advice and encouraging words in between. I discovered he was 20 years old; I could guess this from his appearance. He grew up in Richmond, CA; has one sister; no children; and likes to read physics books. He has a good relationship with his father and is hopeful. He has been working at a restaurant at night for the past six months and taking classes during the day to complete his GED. He noted his lack of a GED as the primary reason for not getting a better job as a welder, a skill he acquired during a short stint in jail for doing “something stupid.” He told me that over a year ago, he rode to Oakland with a couple of friends, and they were actually the ones who did the “something stupid.” But he was in the car, and as a result, had to spend six months in jail. Although he described the time in jail as not long but too long, he did not disparage it or imply it was not justified. Instead, he focused on having learned to weld—acquiring a viable skill that could lead to better employment.

As the young man exited the bus, I was filled with trepidation. I wished him luck, encouraged him to complete his GED, and cautioned him to be careful; but I was afraid for him. It is not that I lack optimism or fail to see the potential in young people. If this were so, I would not remain in this field. What troubled me is the data trend for men with his demographic profile.

In March 2012, I participated in the Cities United Youth Summit led by Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter at the National League of City’s Congressional City Conference in Washington, DC. I presented data on the rates of homicide for Black males. As most people are aware, homicide is the leading cause of death for Black males ages 15 to 24 years. My presentation specifically focused on cities with populations of 100,000 or more, identified by the FBI as having the highest per capita murder rate.

Most people are not shocked to hear that cities like Chicago; Detroit; Philadelphia; Baltimore; Washington, DC; Saint Louis; and New Orleans are among those with the greatest numbers of Black males murdered. These are large cities with significant, if not majority, Black populations. However, many will be surprised to see Richmond, CA, on this list. Richmond is small in comparison, but based on its population, has one of the highest homicide rates for Black males—a rate higher than all of the cities mentioned above. In 2009, which is the most recent data available, the homicide rate for Richmond’s Black males was 191 per 100,000. With 159.6 per 100,000, St. Louis had the second highest rate; it is followed by New Orleans (131.5 per 100,000), Baltimore (107.5 per 100,000), Oakland (109.0 per 100,000), and Detroit (101.5 per 100,000).[1]

The young man who shared his story during the 30-minutes bus ride was Black and lives in a city with one of the highest murder rates for men of his race and age. Despite his progress, a grim and very real chance exists that he or someone like him will be the next victim of a violent act that leads to a premature death. This is a sobering fact that will hopefully encourage everyone—including myself—to address and support efforts to end violence within our communities. To paraphrase Michael Nutter, Mayor of Philadelphia, if we can find the culprit in an E. coli outbreak, which often drills down to individual bunches of strawberries and bags of spinach, surely we can put our collective resources together to end violence in our communities.

Atoinette Davis a Senior Program Specialist at NCCD.

[1] FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program Data. Uniform Crime Reporting Program Data, Supplementary Homicide Reports (2009).

Census 2010 and US Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2009, Detailed Tables.


Submitted by Visitor on August 24, 2013 - 1:16am.

our communities are ran and controlled by the Government that thinks we're inferior part animals the Government steals all our resources through taxes and forces us to follow their foolish rules... end the war on black people/drugs and the violence would all but disappear just like it did during prohibition only now its not white people getting gunned down its the blacks they want dead, return the death penalty and allow black men to judge and police our own communities with Gods law and our children would fear killing each other because they won't be promoted to free room and board, but eye for eye life for life... eye for eye doesn't make them both blind it allows them both to see justice, instead of the hypocrisy the Americans have shoved down our throats with their majority vote!

Submitted by Visitor on August 24, 2013 - 2:35am.

The way I see it is that these cities also have the highest number of young black murderers. Why is that never considered a factor. Why are these articles always from the perspective of blacks as victims. What percentage of these murdered black youths were involved in drug trafficking or some other high risk activity? What percentage of these murdered black youth died with felony records? I would be willing to bet that very few of these murdered black youths were murdered on their way to work.

Submitted by Visitor on August 28, 2014 - 8:39am.

Your insight is misguided. Although there is a significant amount of young black males in very dangerous situations that predispose them to the possibility of murder, there is similarly a large amount black males who are victims of circumstances, environment, association, and racism. To single out one precipitating fact and then define all murdered young black males by those reasons is misguided. there is tons of data and facts that support my point in that black males are exposed too many risky situations that are the cause of racial oppression.

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <img src alt height width> <em> <strong> <span> <cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Missing filter. All text is removed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.